Don’t Call Them Sell-Outs: Rise Against Still Knows a Thing or Two About Propaganda [2014]

This piece was originally published at Myspace in July 2014.

No band should want to grow up to be Bad Religion anymore. Thirty-five years have passed since the Los Angeles band first formed, and after 16 albums, they've become punk's most forgone conclusion. Their trajectory, easily mapped by history, first saw them learning early from the prog rock blunders of Into The Unknown, a sophomore slump that killed them and their chances of achieving what risk-taking contemporaries Hüsker Dü and the Minutemen did.

Following a reunion a few years later, Bad Religion stuck more or less to a successful formula that combined topical angst towards the state of the world with some of the catchiest hooks and chord progressions around. Peaking commercially with 1994's Stranger Than Fiction, Bad Religion proceeded to stick to their guns even after parting ways with Atlantic and returning to guitarist Brett Gurewitz's own Epitaph imprint. Each subsequent album politely nudges the group further into the comforts of elder statesmanship. Theirs is a lesson in conservatism, ironically from one of punk's most enduring liberal voices.

Since first releasing The Unraveling in 2001, Rise Against seemed heir apparent to Bad Religion's musical legacy. Sure, both of their debuts were considered by many to be hardcore records, but it was 2003's Revolutions Per Minute, released smack dab in the middle of the 2003 Iraq War, where the band struck upon their accessible protest motif. We'd obviously seen it before, which is more or less why we liked it. The Bush years needed a soundtrack, something that shouted down the contagious lunacy and overreach of the so-called War on Terror. A band whose branded sociopolitical progressivism has led them to repeatedly reference the iconography of protest in their artwork and music videos, Rise Against made propaganda to combat propaganda.

Yet ever since leaving Fat Wreck Chords and signing with the majors, puritanical punks and creaky critics have bemoaned Rise Against's shift towards melody and mainstream. Leave it to a bunch of purported music lovers to get negative about a band getting better at writing and making music. Punk rock integrity doesn't pay the bills and in 2014 it sure as hell doesn't earn you gold records, something of which Rise Against has three. Mere weeks shy of Siren Song of the Counter Culture's tenth anniversary, anyone still ceaselessly flogging some tedious sell-out narrative ought to consider a long walk or a cold shower.

Regardless of whether or not Rise Against considers themselves the second coming of Bad Religion, the Geffen years have been the band's best. Reuniting with the production duo of The Descendents' Bill Stevenson and Jason Livermore for the sixth consecutive time, The Black Market continues the group's evolution into something that can't be defined by spiky jackets, dyed mohawks and bad hygiene. Underrated and overlooked by emotionally stunted rockists who can't see past The Black Keys and Foo Fighters, Rise Against forge forward with a dozen arena-ready cuts like "Awake Too Long" and "Tragedy + Time." Given the overall lack of testicular fortitude in modern rock, these guys deserve a medal for remembering.

Every generation deserves its own Goo Goo Dolls and I'm here to tell you that Rise Against are it now. That's both a compliment and a nod to a generation that remembers when the former band was among its best rockers. More Johnny Rzeznik than Greg Graffin, frontman Tim McIlrath embraces the humanity of his vocal range throughout The Black Market. Referencing Montagues and Capulets, "Methadone" sounds mere few steps away from A Boy Named Goo, deftly never slipping into full-blown Meg Ryan mode. Still, Rise Against has little incentive not to try and be the biggest rock band in the world, halitosis punks and naysayers be damned.

Agitprop takes many forms, from the up-tempo pep of the title track and "The Eco-Terrorist In Me" to the radio-friendly balladry of "People Live Here." Walls are a thematic constant, as in the emblematic lead single "I Don't Want To Be Here Anymore," though the blurring of personal and political is frequently so effective it's near impossible to distinguish one from the other. That feels appropriately purposeful. It would have been a shame for a band as publically political to shed their activism to sell a few more records.

Here, then, is where any and all sell-out babbling should cease. Rise Against hasn't abandoned their principles. Most members of the band identify as straightedge, and all consider themselves vegetarian. Their positions are laid clear in interviews as well as in the lyrics. It is here that they are closest to Bad Religion still, emboldened by their convictions. But neither genre nor folded arms will contain or stifle Rise Against like it did their Californian forbearers. They've been major much longer than they ever were indie, and if anything they've probably turned more kids on to punk than any of their contemporaries. They're their own men, not yours.